Meanwhile, Spencer is telling Caleb that the police think the murders were premeditated and that's why they're looking at the girls. Caleb tells her that they've put it behind them and that therapy isn't a strike against her. Spencer says that she's still overcoming it, and he says it won't make anyone think she's capable of murder. She says that the paper she wrote might and shows it to him. In it, she wrote about the murder of a twenty year old woman (Melodie Harbough) who had been in her honeymoon suite and decided to end her life the night of her wedding. Despite the death being ruled a suicide, the ruling changed to a homicide when a coroner discover she had injuries before the fall. Just like with Charlotte, the woman's neck was broken and her fingernails and hands were wiped clean before she fell off the balcony. Caleb tells her that being back in Rosewood is making her paranoid and that no one is trying to hurt her; he adds that it's a coincidence, but Spencer says that she doesn't think the police will see it that way.
Questions about the new mystery surface as the girls are forced to stay in Rosewood. A restless Aria starts to look suspicious as she heads back to Boston a little too quickly, but could Aria really be the one behind this? As Spencer, Emily and Hanna find themselves back in familiar territory, they aren’t happy to be going about solving this puzzle “the old way.” Meanwhile, Emily continues to lie about her life in California and Alison keeps a close eye on her friends. #PLL #PrettyLittleLiars
